The AirTag Problem

The AirTag Problem

The AirTag has been out on the market for several months now. The product in Apple’s words is designed to ‘help lose your knack of losing things’ and has seen growing popularity in an exceedingly short space of time.

However, some are not using them for their intended purposes. Over recent months, there has been an increasing amount of stories of people using them to track others maliciously. The ease of access, simple setup and small and lightweight design of the product makes it very easy for people to do so. The coin-sized device can be placed easily into pockets and bags. There is also evidence of people attaching them to the underside of cars.

Apple Was Not Naive

Apple was not naive about the potential for this to happen. It is something they addressed on launch, with something they call ‘unwanted tag detection’. If an AirTag has been separated from its owner and has been following someone for some time, the followed person will receive a notification saying that an AirTag has been ‘moving with you’.

The issue is by the time that notification is received, a lot of damage has already happened. The AirTag owner may already have the information they desire. In addition, the victim feels that their safety and privacy is already compromised.

The AirTag Detected Near You screen on the iOS Find My app.

Why AirTag Competitors Have Not Faced The Same Scrutiny

AirTags have only been around for a year, whilst competitors such as Tile have been in the market for several years. Yet the Apple product has faced tenfold the amount of scrutiny.

The most substantial factor in Apple’s problem compared to it’s competitors is the size of its network. AirTags will speak to any iPhone within its vicinity to communicate its location back to its owner. As there are over one billion active iPhones, statistically you are always likely to be in close proximity to one, especially in cities. In turn, this means that you can get almost a real-time location of the AirTag at any given time.

In contrast, competitor networks are much smaller, fundamentally changing their nature. Using Tile as an example, their network is made up of phones with the Tile app installed on them. Tile claim they have sold over 40 million devices. Considering that a large share of Tile users will have multiple devices, this indicates that the number of app installs is significantly less. Meaning that the AirTag network has over 960,000,000 more network nodes compared to its biggest competitor. This makes constant real-time location tracking less stringent but still good enough to locate your lost keys when a Tile user does come in range.

There is another feature that AirTags have that others do not. If an AirTag is separated from its owner and has followed someone else for some time, the tracked person will get a notification informing them of the situation. This function is a great feature and should remain in place for sure. It does, however, draw more attention to Apple’s problem in particular, as people are highlighting the issue on social media. Something that competitors are not experiencing.

Changing The Network

It is a tricky one. Apple could swiftly solve the problem by disabling its network and just having the device function on Bluetooth and UWB. Effectively meaning you could only find the device if you were within 30 feet of it. However, this would essentially deteriorate its purpose and arguably remove its USP compared to competitors.

They could change how they manage the network and allow people to opt-out of the Find My network just for AirTags. But will enough people do that for it to make a difference? And on the flip-side, if you had to force people to opt-in, would people permit something they feel may lead to an invasion of privacy? Especially iPhone users who do not own an AirTag themselves and would therefore not feel the benefit.

The problem with these routes is once you deplete the network, it essentially deteriorates the product’s usefulness and arguably its unique selling point compared to competitors. Many existing users would have purchased an AirTag based on the ability to track their device accurately and near enough at all times.

Other Routes For The AirTag

The route of increased legal capability would unquestionably cause the impact Apple would like to see when it comes to reducing malicious use. But it may get into murky waters quickly regarding user privacy if law enforcement is punishing people via Apple’s network.

The best route for Apple may be more stringent and pragmatic software updates. For example, they could make the minimum time frame to alert users that they are potentially getting tracked even tighter. This change will need to be defined with balance, as if the window is too narrow, the tweak could cause a swarm of false alerts.

The need to act is seemingly becoming urgent. There are an increasing amount of stories showing malevolent usage of AirTags. It is poor for Apple from a PR perspective alone. Taking into consideration that the company takes privacy and trust so seriously. But the main point is that people’s safety is being put at risk by one of their products. And even though it is not necessarily the technology causing it, the company have a responsibility to protect people’s welfare where they can.

Categories:

AirTag Apple Technology

Keep On Reading

Building Habits With TickTick

TickTick has grown in popularity over recent years. It is one of the only full-fledged productivity apps with a dedicated habit feature.

iPhone Releases Are Plateauing

For a long period of time, iPhone releases were filled with revolutionary advances. Now upgrades are of a smaller scale and that’s okay.